Fallout 4 Cabot House: Kill or Free Lorenzo?

Fallout 4 has many quests which require you to make an impactful choice, and one of these is The Secret of Cabot House where you will eventually need to decide whether to free or kill a character named Lorenzo.

This article will take you through whether you should kill or free Lorenzo in Cabot House of Fallout 4.

• Should You Kill or Free Lorenzo in Fallout 4?
  • What Happens If You Kill Lorenzo?
  • What Happens If You Free Lorenzo?
• Is Lorenzo Evil in Fallout 4?
• Can You Get Lorenzo’s Helmet?
• Are There Any Other Ways to Deal With Lorenzo in Fallout 4?

Should You Kill or Free Lorenzo in Fallout 4?

I recommend killing Lorenzo at the end of the quest due to the fact you get the Artifact Gun, which is an excellent weapon and something you won’t be able to get otherwise. However, if you feel guilty of killing a character who has been locked away, then your moral reasoning may push you to the other option. Morality-wise, killing Lorenzo still generally seems like the best outcome for the Wasteland for reasons I will explain later.

What Happens If You Kill Lorenzo?

If you kill Lorenzo, which you do by flipping the four switches on the walls, you head back to Cabot House with Jack where he gives you about 500 caps. If you were kind to him throughout the mission like I was, he will tell you to come back in a week. You can use sleep and wait to make the time pass faster if you need to, or just keep playing and let the week pass by. The mission will update once it has, so you’ll know when to head back.

Once there, Jack will give you Lorenzo’s Artifact Gun, a Gamma Gun with a special perk. This gun does a decent amount of damage, but its true value is in the various effects of the mod. It can stagger enemies and will deal damage in different ways depending on certain factors. It’s one of the best weapons in Fallout 4, and I’ve found it can help you get through plenty of sticky situations.

What Happens If You Free Lorenzo?

If you decide to free Lorenzo, the mission becomes a whole other affair. Once free, Lorenzo will ask if you wish to help him kill his family. Again, be careful what companion you have here as there are a lot of morally grey actions going on. Whatever you tell Lorenzo here isn’t important; just head back to Cabot House for the rest of the mission.

Once there, you are then presented with the opportunity to switch allegiances. If you side with Jack and the rest of the Cabot family, you’ll have a very tough fight against Lorenzo (use the Mysterious Serum you found at the asylum to make it much easier). In the end, you’ll get the caps, but not the gun.

If you stick with Lorenzo like I didn’t do, you’ll assist in killing the Cabot family, though it should be pretty easy, especially if you convince Edward to join your side. Once it’s over, Lorenzo will give you about 500 caps and explain the new deal. You can swing by the Cabot House to grab more Mysterious Serum at any time. You can only ever have one vial at a time, which cannot be traded or sold. Once it’s used, just head back and grab some more.

This serum gives you a considerable Strength boost, as well as a ton of damage resistance and rad resistance. I have found it to be greatly useful throughout the game, so there is no harm in going with this route. If you are willing to slaughter a not-so-innocent family, this could be the best option. Just have Piper or Curie head to one of your settlements before the fighting begins.

Is Lorenzo Evil in Fallout 4?

Yes, in my opinion, Lorenzo is evil. If he gets out and isn’t killed, there have been reports of players noticing Lorenzo going on murdering sprees across the wasteland in a serial killer-like fashion. This is not the sign of a morally sane man — rather the opposite — so killing him and acquiring the Artifact Gun isn’t too bad an outcome.

Can You Get Lorenzo’s Helmet?

It is not possible to get Lorenzo’s Helmet by normal methods in Fallout 4. However, if you are playing on a PC, then you can easily use console commands to acquire and equip the helmet. The name of the headpiece is Lorenzo’s Crown, and to bring up console commands, you need to press the “~” key. When you do, type: “player.additem 001467F5” and then confirm that with the enter key.

You will now have Lorenzo’s Crown in the game, but to equip it, you will need to type “player.equipitem 001467F5” and then enter. Now you can happily go around the Wasteland with a brilliant fashion sense on display.

Are There Any Other Ways to Deal With Lorenzo in Fallout 4?

No, you only get two choices to deal with Lorenzo and that will come down to your personal decision of what you think is best. We have explained the reasoning behind each choice, so hopefully, that will allow you to make an easier decision — The Cabot House certainly has a lot of morality involved.

After you get through the choices you need to make with Lorenzo, you can happily walk away with whatever you decide to gain from the quest. Whether you decide to free or kill Lorenzo, we know that you will make the choice that matters the most to you similar to the Pickman’s Gift quest.